Beyond Better Than Sex: 7 Luxurious Mascaras That Complement Your Favorite Too Faced Formula

Published on: November 21, 2024
Hero Image of product the-eye-set
Hero Image of product the-concealer-brush
Hero Image of product eye-primer
Hero Image of product the-fluffy-brush
Hero Image of product eyebrow-tint
Hero Image of product glow-on-highlighting-blush
Hero Image of product tinted-skincare-lineup-with-bb-burst
Hero Image of product sunset-daze-bronzing-drops
1 / 0
Let's face it - Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara has earned its spot in countless makeup bags. While its hourglass brush and volumizing formula create undeniably dramatic lashes, we believe in the power of options. Whether you're craving a natural look for morning meetings or planning to layer products for an evening out, these seven mascaras can expand your lash possibilities beyond your trusted Too Faced standby.

HD Mascara - The Hidden Drugstore Diamond

LA Girl's HD Mascara proves that innovation doesn't always come with a luxury price tag. The densely bristled brush offers something distinctly different from Better Than Sex's voluminous approach, focusing instead on precise definition and separation.
We're intrigued by the buildable formula that transitions smoothly from subtle to striking. The inclusion of lash-conditioning ingredients adds an unexpected touch of sophistication to this budget-friendly option. For those blessed with straight lashes, this formula's impressive curl-holding power makes it a practical addition to any mascara wardrobe.

Why we like LA Girl

  • 1

    Budget-Friendly Quality

    Delivers high-end results at drugstore prices

  • 2

    Precise Definition

    Dense bristles separate and define each lash

  • 3

    Curl Retention

    Impressive holding power for straight lashes

Rise Mascara - The Hemp-Powered Innovator

Milk Makeup's Rise Mascara brings something unexpected to the table with its plant-based approach. The curved brush design catches those typically elusive corner lashes, while the hemp-derived cannabis seed oil formula reflects the brand's commitment to thinking outside the conventional beauty box.
The lightweight texture creates an interesting counterpoint to Better Than Sex's more dramatic formula. We're particularly interested in how the vitamin B5 and hemp oil combination works to strengthen lashes over time. The fanned-out effect it creates offers a different kind of drama - less about thickness and more about creating that wide-eyed, awake look that can be worn solo or layered.

Why we like Milk Makeup

  • 1

    Innovative Formula

    Hemp-derived cannabis seed oil strengthens lashes

  • 2

    Corner Lash Coverage

    Curved brush design reaches every lash

  • 3

    Lightweight Feel

    Creates drama without heaviness

Mascara 101 - The "No-Makeup Makeup" Master

Saie's Mascara 101 speaks to those moments when subtlety trumps drama. The slim brush design takes a different approach from Better Than Sex's bold brush, focusing on precision and definition rather than pure volume.
The beeswax and arginine-enriched formula represents a thoughtful balance between makeup and lash care. What catches our attention is the formula's flexibility - it doesn't turn brittle or flaky as the day progresses. This adaptability makes it an interesting option for those unpredictable days that might start with a casual breakfast and end with impromptu evening plans.

Why we like Saie

  • 1

    Natural Look

    Perfect for subtle, everyday wear

  • 2

    Flexible Formula

    Stays soft and flake-free all day

  • 3

    Nourishing Ingredients

    Beeswax and arginine support lash health

Lashlift - The Humidity-Defying Wonder

Drawing inspiration from Asian beauty innovation, Sunnies Face Lashlift tackles the specific challenges of maintaining lifted lashes in humid conditions. The micro-bristled brush offers a stark contrast to Better Than Sex's fuller brush, targeting those with shorter or sparser lashes.
The inclusion of peptides and panthenol in the waterproof formula reflects current skincare-meets-makeup trends. We're particularly interested in its potential as a base coat - the curl-maintaining properties could provide a strong foundation for Better Than Sex's volumizing effects, especially in challenging weather conditions.

Why we like Sunnies Face

  • 1

    Humidity Resistant

    Maintains curl in challenging weather

  • 2

    Micro-Bristle Design

    Perfect for short or sparse lashes

  • 3

    Waterproof Formula

    Long-lasting wear with skincare benefits

Lash Sculpt - The Architectural Visionary

Refy's Lash Sculpt approaches lash enhancement with an architect's eye for precision. The curved brush design represents a different philosophy from Better Than Sex's volume-first approach, prioritizing careful separation and intentional shaping.
The inclusion of lash-strengthening peptides and botanical extracts suggests thoughtful formulation. We're drawn to how the unique brush design tackles those often-overlooked corner lashes. The buildable nature of the formula opens up interesting possibilities for both subtle definition and dramatic styling.

Why we like Refy

  • 1

    Architectural Precision

    Sculpts and shapes each lash

  • 2

    Strategic Design

    Curved brush reaches corner lashes

  • 3

    Versatile Application

    Buildable from subtle to dramatic

The Big Clean Mascara - The Lash Treatment Revolutionist

Kosas The Big Clean Mascara reflects the growing intersection of skincare and makeup. The peptide-rich formula and rainbow-shaped brush create an interesting alternative to Better Than Sex's more traditional approach to lash enhancement.
The emphasis on botanical proteins and vitamins suggests a longer-term perspective on lash care. We're particularly curious about its potential for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers who might need to alternate between intense and gentle formulas. The natural volume it creates offers a different kind of drama - more sophisticated than theatrical.

Why we like Kosas

  • 1

    Treatment-Based

    Peptides and proteins nourish lashes

  • 2

    Gentle Formula

    Suitable for sensitive eyes

  • 3

    Sophisticated Volume

    Creates natural-looking fullness

Clean Lash Lengthening Mascara - The Tubing Technology Pioneer

MERIT's Clean Lash brings tubing technology into the clean beauty space. The widely-spaced bristle pattern creates an interesting contrast to Better Than Sex's dense brush, focusing on precise separation rather than dramatic volume.
The innovative tubing formula represents a different approach to long-wearing makeup. We're intrigued by how this technology creates definition without weight, potentially making it an ideal first layer before adding volume with Better Than Sex. The smudge-resistant properties suggest practical benefits for long days or unpredictable weather.

Why we like MERIT

  • 1

    Innovative Technology

    Clean beauty tubing formula

  • 2

    Weightless Definition

    Separates without heaviness

  • 3

    Smudge-Resistant

    Perfect for layering or long wear

Building Your Lash Wardrobe

These seven mascaras each bring unique technologies and benefits to complement your Better Than Sex Mascara. Think of them as different brushes in an artist's kit - each one creates its own effect, while working harmoniously with others. Whether worn alone or layered strategically, these options expand your lash possibilities while maintaining the health of your natural lashes.