8 Educational Toy Brands Making Melissa & Doug Look Like Child's Play

Published on: November 16, 2024
Hero Image of product pinboard
Hero Image of product beats-to-go
Hero Image of product kindness-is-contagious
Hero Image of product giraffe-push-toy
Hero Image of product avenlur-wooden-rainbow-peg-dolls-figuers-12-piece-set
Hero Image of product woodland-alphabet-cards
Hero Image of product the-play-gym
Hero Image of product swim-club
1 / 0
Remember wooden puzzles and pretend play sets from Melissa & Doug? While they've dominated playrooms for decades, a new generation of toy makers is redefining what educational playthings can be. These innovative brands aren't just creating alternatives – they're revolutionizing how we think about learning through play, with fresh approaches to sustainability, artistic expression, and child development.

: Where Puzzles Meet Gallery-Worthy Art

We're intrigued by how JIGGY has transformed the humble jigsaw puzzle into a celebration of emerging female artists. Their Swim Club puzzle, featuring Belgian artist Isabelle Vandeplassche's dreamlike illustrations, feels more like a curated art piece than a traditional puzzle.
The experience goes beyond mere puzzle-solving. Each set includes preservation materials, allowing the completed work to transition from activity to wall art. Their commitment to sustainability extends to carbon-neutral shipping practices, though we appreciate that they don't let environmental consciousness overshadow the artistic mission at the core of their brand.

Why we like JIGGY

  • 1

    Artist Collaboration

    Showcases and supports emerging female artists

  • 2

    Dual Purpose

    Transforms from activity to displayable art

  • 3

    Sustainable Practices

    Implements carbon-neutral shipping

: Minimalist Play Spaces That Don't Scream "Kids' Stuff"

The Gathre Pinboard represents a refreshing departure from the typical riot of primary colors found in children's organizational tools. Founded by friends Jess and Mare, this brand approaches children's items with an architect's eye for clean lines and a parent's understanding of practical needs.
Their philosophy challenges the notion that children's items must be temporary or aesthetically jarring. We're particularly drawn to their use of premium materials – from bonded leather to high-grade textiles – that maintain their sophistication even in the chaos of family life. Their manufacturing process mirrors the attention to detail typically reserved for luxury goods.

Why we like Gathre

  • 1

    Sophisticated Design

    Elegant aesthetics that complement adult spaces

  • 2

    Premium Materials

    Uses high-grade materials for lasting quality

  • 3

    Practical Innovation

    Combines functionality with sophisticated design

: Musical Innovation from America's Heartland

In their Minneapolis workshop, Manhattan Toy has spent forty years quietly perfecting the art of developmental play. Their Beats To Go musical set showcases their talent for embedding educational value within seemingly simple designs. The brand's extensive testing protocol ensures each product hits the sweet spot between challenge and achievability.
The creative team's methodology reflects decades of refinement. With over 500 products in their portfolio, each design serves specific developmental goals while maintaining the potential for open-ended play. We appreciate how they've resisted the industry trend toward planned obsolescence, creating toys that evolve alongside children's abilities.

Why we like Manhattan Toy

  • 1

    Proven Expertise

    40 years of developmental toy design experience

  • 2

    Rigorous Testing

    Extensive product testing for optimal development

  • 3

    Longevity Focus

    Creates evolving toys that grow with children

: Scientific Design Meets Modern Aesthetics

The Lalo Play Gym exemplifies how contemporary design can serve developmental needs without compromising style. This brand stands out for its collaboration with child development experts to create multipurpose play systems that adapt to different growth stages.
Their approach to customer relationships breaks new ground in the toy industry. The 100-day trial period suggests genuine confidence in their products' lasting value. We're interested in their community engagement, particularly their support of organizations focused on fertility, perinatal care, and education – areas that align naturally with their mission but often get overlooked in the toy sector.

Why we like Lalo

  • 1

    Expert Collaboration

    Partners with child development specialists

  • 2

    Customer Confidence

    Offers 100-day trial period

  • 3

    Community Impact

    Supports fertility and education initiatives

: High-Contrast Design for Developing Minds

The story behind Wee Gallery's Woodland Alphabet Cards reflects founders Surya and Dave's deep dive into infant visual development. Their signature high-contrast, nature-inspired aesthetic isn't just striking – it's rooted in scientific understanding of how babies process visual information.
The brand's evolution demonstrates sophisticated thinking about developmental stages. Their products transform alongside children: what starts as visual stimulation for infants becomes a language learning tool for toddlers, then transitions into reading preparation for preschoolers. We find this built-in adaptability particularly clever.

Why we like Wee Gallery

  • 1

    Scientific Design

    Based on infant visual development research

  • 2

    Adaptive Use

    Products evolve with child's development

  • 3

    Nature-Inspired

    Incorporates natural themes in high-contrast designs

: Movement-First Play Design

Avenlur's Wooden Rainbow Peg Dolls Figures showcase how traditional materials can serve contemporary developmental needs. The brand's focus on physical development alongside cognitive growth reflects current research about the interconnected nature of learning.
Their approach to safety certification (ASTM & CPSIA) goes beyond mere compliance. We're impressed by their consideration of both structured and spontaneous play opportunities within single products. Their sustainable manufacturing practices suggest a holistic understanding of responsibility that extends beyond immediate user safety.

Why we like Avenlur

  • 1

    Holistic Development

    Integrates physical and cognitive learning

  • 2

    Safety Excellence

    Exceeds standard safety certifications

  • 3

    Versatile Play

    Supports both structured and spontaneous play

: Heartland Craftsmanship Meets Modern Values

From their Iowa workshop, Jesse and Stacey Bannor are writing a new chapter in American toy making. Their Giraffe Push Toy demonstrates how traditional craftsmanship can serve contemporary educational needs. The use of local hardwoods and non-toxic finishes reflects their understanding that quality starts with raw materials.
Their zero-waste policy provides a blueprint for responsible manufacturing. Our favorite detail? Even their sawdust ends up in the workshop compost pile. This attention to environmental impact, combined with their focus on creating inheritance-worthy toys, offers a compelling alternative to disposable play things.

Why we like Bannor Toys

  • 1

    Local Materials

    Uses sustainably sourced local hardwoods

  • 2

    Zero Waste

    Implements comprehensive waste reduction

  • 3

    Heirloom Quality

    Creates durable, inheritance-worthy toys

: Nostalgia Reimagined for Modern Play

Le Puzz's Kindness Is Contagious puzzle brings vintage charm into the present with random-cut pieces and extra-thick cardboard. The founders' background in vintage puzzle collecting informs their design choices, creating an experience that feels both familiar and fresh.
We're drawn to their holistic approach to the puzzle experience, from FSC-approved materials to minimalist packaging. Their partnership with the Boys & Girls Club of America demonstrates an understanding that play should transcend economic boundaries. The result is a product line that honors puzzle tradition while pushing toward a more inclusive future.

Why we like Le Puzz

  • 1

    Vintage Inspiration

    Incorporates classic puzzle-making techniques

  • 2

    Quality Materials

    Uses FSC-approved materials and premium cardboard

  • 3

    Social Impact

    Partners with youth development organizations

A New Chapter in Educational Play

These brands signal a shift in how we think about learning through play. By emphasizing sustainability, artistic collaboration, and developmental science, they're creating products that serve multiple purposes throughout childhood. Each company brings its own perspective to the challenge of creating meaningful play experiences, suggesting that the future of educational toys will be more diverse, thoughtful, and enduring than ever before.